The interminable problems Microsoft seems to be having with Vista made me think of the argument Joseph Tainter made in The Collapse of Complex Societies.
I should probably disclose that I’m a relatively contented XP user who plans to soon take cyber-refuge in OS X.* And that I haven’t actually read Tainter’s book!
I’ve read a fair bit on it though. That is, if Wikipedia counts as “a fair bit”.
OK, enough joking around… after all, this blog is “chatter from a fallen monkey” not “dissertations from a risen paramecium”.
Tainter argued that the ultimate cause for societal collapse is diminishing returns on investments in social complexity. In the “house of cards” model, eventually, adding complexity to a society makes it only little more productive — but a lot less resilient.
Using a biological context, single-cultivar agricultural monoculture might be a good example: crop yields might be a little higher (diminished return)…
…but if there’s a blight or pest, you could lose the entire crop (less resilient).
See here for a current example.
- - - - -
In the context of Windows Vista, I wonder if the OS has become so huge and so complex (so bloated?) that there are meagre returns on its increasing complexity, relative to the alternative (say, Windows XP).
If that’s what happens to a society before it collapses, I wonder what Microsoft will do for post-Vista Windows OS’s, such as Vienna. Will there be a point where Microsoft says “there’s no business case in building the Windows OS further” and instead try to ‘reboot’ by launching a simpler, stripped-down Windows — e.g. building everything around Windows CE? More trivially, will Apple still be running those Mac-vs-PC ads?
=====
* given that all the OS X names seem to come from big cats (cheetah, leopard, jaguar…) I assume the person in charge isn’t a “dog person”. Wonder what’s next — Leo? (”Lion” sounds too much like “lying” so it probably isn’t appropriate.) Lynx would be cool, if only for the consumer confusion caused by having Linux, Lynx and Unix OS’s in the marketplace…