This is the most encouraging news I’ve seen coming out of Alberta in a good long while. Sadly, the Globe and Mail still has a ridiculous paywall policy for anything more than a week old. So, in case this is being read after end-Feb, the news is this: the tar sands lobby has splintered!
Like Joe Biden in a Vice-Presidential debate, I’ll repeat that one more time: the tar sands lobby has splintered! Good to see the dirty-oil campaign has won some success.
This is a classic divide-and-conquer victory: fracturing your opponents and getting them to outflank each other, instead of you. Wonderful stuff.
- - - - -
Basically, newer tar sands players using maybe-not-quite-as-lethally-destructive steam-assisted gravity-drainage extraction (SAGD) are trying to separate themselves from traditional tar sands miners.
The process is even more energy intensive than traditional tar sands mining, but it should be possible to extract the bitumen without denuding the boreal forest above. The process should use less fresh water, and eliminates the need for visible-from-space tailings ponds.
While the only “clean” tar sands are the ones left in the ground, I think SAGD could be marginally less environmentally destructive, on the whole. Whether a lifecycle analysis confirms this or shows otherwise, it is absolutely refreshing to see the tar sands lobby splintering.